National reforms needed to make surrogacy more accessible and responsible

The Australian Law Reform Commission (ALRC) has recommended a new, national approach to surrogacy that would make responsible domestic surrogacy easier to access while better protecting children, surrogates and intended parents from exploitation. 

In its Final Report tabled in Parliament today, Enhancing Responsible Access: An Effective Regulatory Framework for Surrogacy, the ALRC has found that Australia’s current patchwork of state and territory laws makes domestic surrogacy unnecessarily difficult and uncertain for intended parents, does not adequately protect the rights of children and can leave surrogates financially disadvantaged.  

The ALRC finds that these barriers are likely contributing to Australians pursuing overseas surrogacy – which now accounts for around 80% of surrogacy arrangements undertaken by Australians. Over 300 Australian children are born into overseas surrogacy arrangements each year, where the risks of exploitation and other forms of harm are significant.  

The ALRC recommends a nationally consistent framework designed to make well-regulated domestic surrogacy more accessible and fair, strengthen safeguards for all involved, and provide more effective regulation of overseas surrogacy undertaken by Australians.  

On the release of the Report, ALRC President, Justice Mordy Bromberg said:  

“For a long time, surrogacy has been a legitimate form of family formation in every Australian state and territory for people who may otherwise be unable to have children. Good surrogacy laws should do two things: enable people to form families through surrogacy where it can be undertaken responsibly; and provide effective safeguards against exploitation and harm. Our current laws do not achieve either aim. Instead they drive Australians to pursue overseas surrogacy arrangements, which can expose children, surrogates, and intended parents to great risk of harm and exploitation.”

“Our 47 recommendations provide a blueprint for a nationally consistent surrogacy framework that is both more accessible and more protective. If implemented, they would encourage Australians to form families through surrogacy at home, and better protect the rights of children, surrogates and intended parents.”

Key reforms recommended in the report include: 

  • Creating a nationally consistent surrogacy framework, with a National Regulator to provide oversight, guidance and consistent administration. 
  • Making domestic surrogacy easier to access, including through licensed, fee-capped ‘Surrogacy Support Organisations’. 
  • Protecting surrogates from financial disadvantage, while retaining the prohibition on surrogacy for profit or reward. 
  • Providing greater certainty about legal parentage, including an administrative pathway for approved domestic arrangements that comply with the safeguards. 
  • Strengthening safeguards before surrogacy commences, including requirements relating to independent legal advice, counselling, medical screening, criminal history checks for intended parents, and a compliant written surrogacy agreement. 
  • Establishing a National Surrogacy Register, to better protect the right of children born through surrogacy to information about their identity. 
  • Introducing a new national framework for overseas surrogacy, requiring intended parents to register before entering an overseas arrangement, obtain official guidance and Australian and overseas legal advice, and take reasonable steps to avoid arrangements involving significant risks. 
  • Replacing ineffective criminal prohibitions with more enforceable civil penalties and nationally consistent oversight. 

Background 

More Australians are using surrogacy to grow their families each year, through both domestic and overseas arrangements. Estimates are that there were 84 domestic surrogacy births in 2023, up from 27 in 2014. However, more than 300 children are born each year through overseas surrogacy arrangements, representing around 4 in 5 of the Australian children born through surrogacy.  

On 6 December 2024, the Commonwealth Attorney-General referred a review of surrogacy laws to the ALRC. The Inquiry’s Terms of Reference asked the ALRC to review Australia’s surrogacy laws, policies and practices, and to propose reforms, particularly regarding uniform or complementary laws across Australian jurisdictions, and reforms that are consistent with Australia’s obligations under international laws and conventions. The Terms of Reference also asked the ALRC to consider: reducing barriers to domestic ‘altruistic’ surrogacy, including appropriate reimbursements for surrogates; how Australian law handles overseas surrogacy arrangements, including legal parentage; and the information available to children born through surrogacy, including information on birth certificates. 

The ALRC received 1,697 submissions and consulted with more than 120 individuals and organisations during the Inquiry. The Final Report makes 47 recommendations. 

The ALRC’s Review of the Future Acts Regime was led by ALRC President, the Honourable Justice Mordy Bromberg, supported by Associate Professor Ronli Sifris and the ALRC’s Inquiry Team.  

Learn more about the review at www.alrc.gov.au/inquiry/review-of-surrogacy-laws. 

Links 

Enhancing Responsible Access: An Effective Regulatory Framework for Surrogacy (ALRC Report 145) 

 

ENDS 

 

To arrange interviews or for more information contact: 

Jez Hunghanfoo 
Director of Communications and Information 
P: 03 9959 5313 
E: [email protected] 
W: www.alrc.gov.au